Verbatim and the Morality of Using the Words of Others

Photos by Linford Butler
Photos by Linford Butler

Verbatim theatre along with documentary theatre has become increasingly popular over the last twenty years. The central concept of verbatim is that you put the real words of real people on stage as near as possible to how they were spoken. Some of the first works of verbatim theatre to gain notoriety include Richard Norton-Taylor’s The Colour of Justice which used the court records to recreate key moments in the Stephen Lawrence murder trial. The Colour of Justice has since become very influential and many agree played some part in the inquiry and the Macpherson report that followed. The playwright Robin Soans has said that a certain amount of expectations have built up around Verbatim theatre and that an audience “will expect the play to be political” (Soans in Hammond and Stewart, 2010, 19) in the last few years however many have challenged this preconception and shown that verbatim can be more about the people than the politics.

Alecky Blythe wrote The Girlfriend Experience about the way prostitution works in modern Britain and while it was partly political it was made far more remarkable by the people and their real lives being displayed as they never have been before. Her next play was to eradicate politics almost completely London Road was about a community recovering from finding a murderer in their midst. Breaking the mould once more London Road is the first verbatim musical and this seems to indicate that Verbatim has lost it’s sacred status and that it is open more to poetic licence and experimentation.

In the above clip a range of verbatim writers talk about the balance to be struck between representing the interviewee and creating good theatre. Alecky Blythe expresses how she finds herself taking bigger leaps in poetic licence as her career has gone on. London Road as a play is the closest to Three Words of any verbatim play I’ve read because it concerns itself only with the people, what they do, and how they feel. It is verbatim used to bring new voices and perspectives into the theatre, it puts the humanity of its characters on display to the audience.

This too is what we wanted, people will always be at the centre of Three Words and we needed to inject a healthy dose of reality to ensure we were not making exactly the kind romance that Hollywood seems to incapable of escaping. That was when we made our decision to find as many interviewees and use their stories as the backbone of the show. We use verbatim in several places, much of it recorded, here is one piece that made it without any editing into the show.

In other places we have had to do as Alecky Blythe has done and edit, merge or downright invent stories for the purposes of making the show easy to follow. ‘The 2p Train’ was a based on a story from within the company and one from outside, we spoke to the outside party and presented them with our script for their confirmation. This type of merging is mentioned in the above video by the director Nadia Fall and it is commonly used in order to simplify the amount of characters the audience has to follow. As we only really had two characters throughout the show a lot of merging took place but always with the express consent of those we spoke to.

The clip above shows that Verbatim has lost some of the puritanical attention to detail that companies like Blythe’s Recorded Delivery developed in favour of something a little more theatrical. It has past the point of being simply political in the way that it was for writers like David Hare and Robin Soans. Verbatim is developing into more than a set of rules into another tool for storytellers to use. It brings people into the theatre that would never normally cross the threshold let alone step on stage and celebrates their stories. Verbatim is really the only way to truly represent people and that’s what Three Words is all about.

Works Cited

Blythe, A (2011) London Road. London: Nick Hern Books.

Blythe, A (2008) The Girlfriend Experience. London: Nick Hern Books.

Hammond, W & Steward, D. (eds.) (2010) Verbatim Verbatim. London: Oberon Books.

National Theatre (2014) The ethics of verbatim theatre. [online video] Available from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=39JSv-n W5U [accessed 4 May 2014].

Norten-Taylor, R. (1999) The Colour of Justice. London: Oberon Books.

“Love is… Lovely, isn’t it?”

Below are the full sound recordings of the interviews I conducted. I asked a few questions about love and relationships. Beneath the sound recordings are some moments I have highlighted, and quotations that stood out to us as material for the piece.

 

 

Interview with a single man in his mid-twenties:

What kind of tough conversations have you had in your relationships?

“Making things official… without officially talking about them…”

 

Any landmark moments?

“…The size of the moment, the grandeur of it is on the situation, or the circumstance of how the two came together.”

 

What do you think of love?

“Love is lovely isn’t it?” “What is the borderline moment between when you really care, and really like someone… When does that become love?”

 

Do you believe in ‘love at first sight’?

“No no no, I know there is no such thing as ‘love at forst sight’, that is lust, that is simply love. It’s there, in the name, ‘sight’. Because when you see someone, it’s there, like boom, “you are fit mate”. Like, then they could open their mouth and it’d be like, the most hideous voice. Yeah, it would be the worst thing in the world.”

 

How long should you know someone before you say ‘I love you’?

“Because when you say ‘I love you’, it suddenly means something. I can only compare it to… when people throw around the term ‘best friend’… As soon as you put the label of ‘bets friend’ on someone, that suddenly makes them the one, they’re accountable and that is scary because you depend on someone, much like… well, it’s scary cos they could let you down… I think that’s why saying ‘I love you’ would be terrifying, because as soon as you’ve said it, you can’t take that back, and because… because it’s a display of emotion, and how you feel summed up in like three little words… You wanna run away from it, like if you don’t say it, you don’t put it on someone, they can’t let you down, and then like, its easier to accept someone’s faults when you haven’t put that on someone, put them in that position, on that pedestal. You know, “you’re the one I love, don’t fuck it up!” and “you’re my best friend, don’t fuck it up!” Same thing, isn’t it.”

 

Do you have any ground rules in your relationships?

“Just… be honest.”

 

Interview with a young couple:

What kind of tough conversations have you had in your relationships?

Girlfriend: I actually can’t remember any tough conversations.

Boyfriend: It’s probably like… what shall we have for dinner innit?

Girlfriend: Ha, yeah… ‘We should probably keep this secret for a bit because we’re flat mates.’ Oh and he asked me if Jennifer Anniston could go on his [bucket] list.

 

Any landmark moments?

Me: So you’re first anniversary, was that really special?

 

Silence… Laughter.

 

Me: It’s a voice recording, shaking you’re head isn’t useful!

Girlfriend: Well I think the first time he said ‘I love you’ was nice.

 

What do you think of love?

Boyfriend: It’s just, alright, innit.

Girlfriend: I’d say it was more than alright! I think he’s being a bit, harsh on Love there. I mean, I’d say it’s pretty sweet… pretty sweet… (Laughter).

 

How long should you wait before you say ‘I love you’?

Girlfriend: If you feel like you do, then why not just say it?

Boyfriend: I said it first… I’m a good boy.

Girlfriend: And it was really nice, cos it was really… of the cuff.

Gestes de la Romance…

Because everything is more romantic in French.

 

Romantic gestures. Big, small, surprising, embarrassing, adorable or sexy – these gestures of love keep our relationships alive. They feed, what is often called, ‘the spark’.

Ask anyone about this subject and you usually hear: “no… we’re/he’s/she’s just not that romantic really!” Of course, we could all be overlooking the tiniest of details in our relationships: That morning cup of tea, picking you up when it’s raining. And why are we oblivious to these charming acts of love? Because films, books and television seem to shroud our honest lives with some grand idea that the only way you can keep a relationship going is to hijack a hot air balloon and whisk them off to Barbados, where you’re greeted by Sonny Rollins, who plays a saxophone solo as you have a walk along the beach… or something similar. I suppose we should not be totally cynical about it though, these films are not reality by any means, but I think it keeps the hopeless romantic topped up in all of us. For example, the brilliant scene in ’10 Things I Hate About You’, where Patrick sings to Kat on the school field:

In light of this, my quest was to find real stories that are near enough film worthy. The criteria included: gestures of love, romantic surprises, or getting together against the odds. These are some of the true stories that came through…

“My Nan moved from Italy when she was about 24, with 20 other Italian girls. They worked in a factory or something and lodged with English families. She lived with my Grandad’s family (he was away in the army at the time) and another Italian friend. The Italian friend didn’t get on with the family and eventually she left wanting my Nan to go with her but she didn’t. My Grandad’s mum threw a birthday party for my Nan, and that night my Grandad came home. He asked her out on a date, they fell in love! When their children were about 18 months/2 years old my Nan went to Italy for 3 months to see family. My Grandad had to stay and work but missed them so went out on Christmas day without them knowing and suprised my Nan.”

“My friend Amy’s boyfriend Craig turned up on her doorstep, having spent £70 on a taxi to get to her house, with a new dress and a table for dinner booked (think he definitely got head that night).”

“My Grandma and Grandad got together because my grandma was a librarian at the library by Grandad studied at. They talked regularly, and eventually he asked her if she wanted to go out. She politely declined, but he tried again. After several attempts he waited for her after work one day with a bunch of flowers and after that she agreed and they went on a date!”

“My mum was Sikh and therefore was expected to have an arranged marriage. She got a job and started working in the summer holidays. My dad was a security guard who worked close by (he is English), my mum thought he was nice but had never looked at boys in that way before. My dad kept asking for a date, however she explained that she wasn’t allowed to date. My dad was persistent and in the end they had a secret meeting, my mum’s dad dropped her at work but she got on a train to London and made sure she was back on time for work finishing. My mum and dad only ever had one date and one kiss and on that basis my mum changed everything she had known, they started planning on how and when to escape together. My mum packed a bag and left a note to say she was leaving. Her family found out where she was and after a tough two weeks she felt too guilty and agreed to stay with a family’s friend. It was then she realised it was my dad she wanted to be with, but the only way she could be sure was to leave him to find that out. They arranged to move up North and stay with my dad’s uncle. They came up here with a carrier bag of clothes and made their life together. My mum tried to win her family’s love back, it took around 7 or 8 years but eventually it happened. 25 years on they are still together happily married with two children.”

In terms of performance we were inspired by these beautiful and bold stories. However, these are exceptional cases that really are film worthy. But they are few and far between. It inspired us to really consider the small everyday gestures versus the grand. The cups of tea versus the public singing. Therefore, we are starting to think about how to embed the little details into one or more of the scenes, most likely in some of the more serious aspects to the piece. As a sort of experiment we are also planning a grand romantic gesture. It is in the pipeline and will remain a surprise until the night (and will be largely improvised on my part)! This contrast will hopefully highlight the realities of our relationships and how we crave the grand romantic gesture and are possibly neglectful of the little details. But as I said, this is an experiment!